Are smart locks secure?
The honest answer involves separating two questions that usually get mixed up: whether the door is harder to force, and whether access is harder to misuse. They have different answers.
Two different questions hide inside this one, and conflating them is why the usual answers are unsatisfying. The first is whether a smart lock makes your door harder to break down. The second is whether it makes your access harder to abuse. They have different answers and the second one matters more than most people expect.
Does it make the door harder to force?
Mostly, no, and anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something.
A smart lock of the kind we sell replaces the handles and the electronics. The parts that resist a crowbar are the cylinder, the bolt, the strike plate and the frame, and those are either unchanged or replaced with equivalent hardware. A door that could be forced in forty seconds before can be forced in forty seconds after.
So if your concern is physical attack, the smart lock is not the answer. The answers are the ones a locksmith would give you: a correctly sized anti-snap cylinder that finishes flush, a proper strike plate screwed into the frame rather than the architrave, and hinge bolts on an outward opening door. Our guide to measuring a euro cylinder covers the first of those, because an over-length cylinder is a genuine and common weakness.
Does it make access harder to abuse?
Here the answer is yes, substantially, and this is where the real gain is.
Think about how many copies of your key exist. Not how many you issued: how many exist. The previous tenant. The builder who had one for three weeks in 2021. The friend who had one cut without asking. The letting agent. You cannot answer that question, and you cannot do anything about it short of changing the cylinder.
With credentials instead of keys:
- Every credential belongs to one person and can be removed on its own
- A credential can have an expiry date, so access ends without anyone acting
- You know which credential opened the door and when
- Nothing can be copied at a kiosk for three euros
For a rented property that is not a small improvement. It is the difference between hoping and knowing.
Where the real risks are
Being honest about this is more useful than reassurance.
Codes shared casually
The commonest weakness by a distance. Somebody gives a permanent code to a tradesman and never removes it. The fix is behavioural: use time limited codes by default, and permanent codes only for people who genuinely need indefinite access.
Codes observed
Somebody watching from a car can read a code typed on a keypad. This is the same risk as a cash machine, and the same mitigations apply: shield the keypad, and prefer a fingerprint when anyone is about.
The administrator account
Whoever holds it controls every credential on the lock. Use a password you do not use elsewhere, turn on whatever second factor your account offers, and do not let a fitter keep administrator rights after the job.
The cylinder, again
If you fit a smart lock over a cylinder that protrudes, you have added convenience to a door that can still be snapped open in seconds. This is by far the most common real world weakness we see, and it has nothing to do with the electronics.
What about hacking?
It is the thing people ask about and the least likely to affect you. An attacker interested in your flat will try the door, the window or the cylinder, because those take seconds and require no skill. Electronic attacks on a Bluetooth lock require proximity, equipment and expertise, against a target that is usually worth less than the effort.
That said, basic hygiene applies: keep the app updated, do not leave the lock in pairing mode, and do not reuse your account password.
What insurers care about
Generally not whether the lock is smart, but whether the physical specification meets their requirement. If your policy specifies a particular standard for the lock or the cylinder, fitting a smart lock does not exempt you from it, and an over-length cylinder may well breach it. If you are unsure, ask your insurer before buying rather than after a claim.
The summary we would give a friend
Buy a smart lock because you want to control who can get in and to stop handing out keys. Do not buy one expecting it to armour the door. If security is the goal, spend the first hundred euros on a correctly sized anti-snap cylinder and a decent strike plate, and the smart lock after that.
Common questions
Is a smart lock safer than a normal lock?
Against physical force, no: the cylinder, bolt and frame do the work and they are unchanged. Against misuse of access, yes, because credentials belong to one person, can expire and can be revoked.
Can someone hack my smart lock?
It is possible in principle and very unlikely in practice. An electronic attack needs proximity, equipment and skill, against a door that can usually be forced in seconds by simpler means.
What is the most common weakness you actually see?
A cylinder that is too long. Anything protruding more than about three millimetres can be gripped and snapped, which takes seconds and is a recognised method of forcing a door.
Will my insurer accept a smart lock?
Usually, but it depends on whether the physical specification meets their requirement. Ask them before buying, particularly if your policy names a standard for the lock or cylinder.
What if someone watches me type my code?
Treat it like a cash machine: shield the keypad, and use a fingerprint when there are people about. Change a code you think has been seen, which takes seconds.
More guides
- Will a smart lock fit my door? Four checks, none of which needs a tool more specialised than a tape measure. If all four pass,
- Smart locks for offices and shared entrances Access control for a small team, without a server, a contract or a monthly fee. What changes when
- Smart locks for Airbnb and short stay rentals What self check-in really involves once the lock is on the door: the codes, the message you send,